It's pretty amazing that for less than the cost of what I used to pay for a CD, I can have instant access to a library of most of the music that's ever been recorded. Or what feels close enough to "most." Streaming lets me explore with a marginal cost of zero, which means trying out new artists and entire new genres in a way I couldn't when I was a college student, poor, and trying that song or artist or genre cost me at least $15 or $20 or whatever a CD was in those days.

But I think about when I bought Telegraph's album Switched On. You can listen to it on the band’s Bandcamp page. Telegraph was the first ska band I got super into, because they played a ton of shows I'd go to in high school, and they were among the best ska bands in an exceptional Detroit ska scene. So I bought Switched On the day of its release. And didn't like it. Really at all. It didn't sound like the Telegraph I'd been listening to. It was slower. Less pick-it-up-pick-it-up.

What I think about now, when I think about Switched On, is that if it'd come out on Spotify instead of eleven years before Spotify launched in the US, I wouldn't have gotten what happened next. Which is that Switched On became one of my favorite albums. And it became one of my favorite albums because I'd spent $15 or $20 on it when I was a poor college student and so, dammit, I was going to listen to it at least ten times, no matter what I thought of it the first time or two. I don't know when things started to change, but it was probably around the tenth listen. And I kept going and came to love it.

In “Reading Games,” Sadek Kessous says our relationship with artworks depends on "the different modes of attention we pay to their forms." He's talking about games and books, but I wonder how many of those first nine listens I spent waiting for Telegraph to be the Telegraph I was used to. Ten (or however many) listens meant I had to stop waiting, and so heard what they were trying to do instead of what I wanted them to do.

If I'd had Spotify, instead, and Switched On had shown up in my "New releases from artists you follow" feed instead of in a bin at Albums on the Hill in Boulder, I don't know that I would've gotten to whatever that number was when things started to change. I'd have listened once, maybe not even all the way through, and said, "This isn't for me." The zero marginal cost of new music doesn't just mean having access to all the music, but it means having no sense of sunk costs. If I'm paying ten bucks for everything, then Switched On in my feed is free, and so I can drop it like everything else that's free and so disposable. I can move on to the next thing that immediately grabs me, and don't feel an urge to stick with the things that don't, because I didn't pay anything meaningful for them.

How many of my favorite records would I have skipped the first time through?